All insights

Undercharging for delivery? Check carrier costs first

The delivery charge on a customer’s purchase order is decided before the order is packed, so it is based on a guess about weight, size and destination. The carrier’s price is based on what actually leaves the building. When the two differ and nobody compares them, you end up undercharging for delivery, and the gap comes straight out of the margin on the order.

The fix is simple to describe: price the delivery with the carrier once the order is packed, compare that price with the delivery charge on the order, and have a person decide what to do with any difference before the invoice is raised. Most of the work is in making that comparison routine instead of occasional.

Why does the delivery charge on a PO differ from the carrier cost?

The charge on a PO usually comes from one of three places: a flat rate on your price list, a figure the customer copied from a previous order, or a quote someone gave over the phone. All three are made without the packed weight and dimensions. These are the usual reasons the real cost turns out different.

Weight

Carrier tariffs step up at weight bands. An order you expected to fit in one 15kg parcel might pack as two parcels, one of them over a band threshold. A small change in what was ordered can move the cost more than you’d expect.

Dimensions

Most parcel carriers charge on whichever is greater, the actual weight or a volumetric weight calculated from the parcel’s dimensions using a divisor the carrier sets. Light but bulky goods, such as insulation, packaging or plastic fittings in large cartons, can cost far more than their weight suggests. Parcels over a certain length often attract an extra handling charge too.

Surcharges

Fuel surcharges, which many carriers adjust periodically, are easy to forget when a flat delivery charge was set months ago. There may also be charges for timed or weekend delivery, extra handling, or a failed first attempt. Check your own carrier agreement for which apply to you.

Parcels versus pallets

An order that tips over the practical limit for parcels has to go on a pallet. Pallet pricing works differently, usually by pallet size, weight band and destination zone, with extras such as a tail lift or a booked delivery time. Moving from three parcels to a quarter pallet can change the cost considerably in either direction.

Remote postcodes

Many carriers add a surcharge for certain postcode areas, typically including the Scottish Highlands and islands, Northern Ireland and offshore locations. A flat delivery charge on your price list probably doesn’t allow for them.

A worked example

The figures below are invented for illustration and exclude VAT. Your own tariff will look different.

A customer’s PO carries your standard delivery charge of £15.00. The order packs into three cartons weighing 18kg, 22kg and 9kg, going to a postcode in the Highlands. Say your parcel tariff is £7.00 per parcel up to 20kg and £11.00 per parcel from 20kg to 30kg, with a remote area surcharge of £5.00 per parcel and a 5% fuel surcharge on the base price.

Item Calculation Cost
Carton 1 (18kg) up to 20kg band £7.00
Carton 2 (22kg) 20kg to 30kg band £11.00
Carton 3 (9kg) up to 20kg band £7.00
Base price £25.00
Fuel surcharge 5% of £25.00 £1.25
Remote area surcharge 3 x £5.00 £15.00
Carrier cost £41.25
Delivery charge on PO £15.00
Shortfall £41.25 less £15.00 £26.25

Packing changes the figure too. If the 18kg and 9kg items had gone into one 27kg carton, the order would have shipped as two parcels in the 20kg to 30kg band: £22.00 base, £1.10 fuel and £10.00 remote surcharge, so £33.10 in total and a shortfall of £18.10.

A shortfall of £26.25 is small on its own. If an order like it slipped through twice a week for 50 weeks, it would add up to £2,625 a year in delivery costs the business absorbed without deciding to.

How to catch a delivery price mismatch before invoicing

The check has to happen after packing and before the invoice. In practice that means:

  1. Capture weights and dimensions at packing, per parcel or pallet, on the device the packer is already using. Numbers written on paper and typed in later are where errors creep in.
  2. Price the delivery live with the carrier using those packed figures and the delivery postcode, or from your pallet network’s rate card.
  3. Compare the carrier price with the delivery charge on the order. The customer’s PO figure should already be on the sales order from when it was reviewed.
  4. Hold the order if they differ by more than your tolerance, so it can’t be invoiced until someone has looked at it.
  5. Record the decision and who made it, so you can see later how often delivery charges are being adjusted and for which customers.

This is the step our shipping automation handles: when the live carrier price doesn’t match the delivery charge on the customer’s PO, the order is held and the office decides before invoicing. Our earlier post on booking parcels and pallets without the phone calls covers the booking and label printing around it.

What should you do when the delivery charge is wrong?

There are three sensible responses, and the right one depends on the customer and the size of the difference.

Option When it makes sense What happens
Accept the difference Small gap, valued customer, or a price you agreed to honour Invoice as ordered and note why
Amend the order Your terms allow it, or the customer’s PO had no delivery charge Update the delivery charge on the sales order before invoicing
Call the customer Large gap, or a PO that states a fixed delivery price Explain the cost, agree a figure, or offer a cheaper service or later delivery

Amending without telling the customer is where disputes come from. If their PO states a delivery charge, an invoice for a different figure is likely to be queried, and a short phone call before invoicing is cheaper than a credit note afterwards.

Should you set a tolerance?

Probably. Checking every 40p difference wastes time. Many businesses set a threshold below which the carrier cost is accepted, and only differences above it are held. The right figure depends on your typical order value and delivery charge. Review it once you can see how often orders are being held.

Fixing carriage charges upstream

A recurring mismatch usually means the price list needs fixing. If the same customers or postcodes come up again and again, review your delivery charges by weight band or zone instead of using a single flat rate, and make sure customers ordering by email can see what delivery will cost. Checking the delivery charge against the account’s terms when an order is first reviewed catches some of these before anything is packed. Our post on the order approval workflow covers that earlier check.

If you’re absorbing delivery costs you never agreed to and want to see how a live price check would fit your carriers and ERP, book a discovery call. Carrier cost checks are part of our shipping side, which is available on request and priced separately from the plans, and the tolerance and hold rules are set to suit how you work.