All insights

Order processing software: off-the-shelf, custom or managed?

When a wholesaler decides to stop keying in emailed orders, the next decision is usually how. There are three realistic routes: sign up for off-the-shelf order processing software, have a system built for the business, or use a managed platform that’s set up around your systems. All three are reasonable, and the right answer depends on how standard your process is, how many systems the orders touch and how much you want to spend up front.

In short, off-the-shelf software is usually the better choice when your orders and approval process are simple and the product supports your ERP well. A custom build makes sense when your process is unusual enough that nothing else fits, and you have the budget and someone to look after it. A managed platform suits the businesses in between: orders with quirks and several systems involved, but no appetite for a large build or for running the software yourself.

We run a managed platform, so we have an obvious interest. We’ve tried to be fair anyway, because selling a business the wrong thing doesn’t help them or us.

The three options at a glance

Off-the-shelf software Custom build Managed platform
Upfront cost Low: often a set-up fee Highest: the full cost of the build A setup fee to connect your systems (ours: from £1,500 ex VAT, waived on our Growth plan)
Ongoing cost Monthly licence, often by user or volume Hosting, third-party services, maintenance and changes A monthly plan priced by volume (ours: from £295 a month ex VAT)
Time to start Days to weeks The longest, as everything is written first Sooner than a build, as the platform already exists
Fit to your process You adapt to the product Written around your process A proven core, with your integration set up around how you work
ERP integration Whatever connectors the product supports Written for your ERP Configured for your ERP and how you use it
Changes On the vendor’s roadmap You decide, and pay for the work Small tweaks included or billed hourly, depending on the plan; platform features on the provider’s roadmap
Commitment Varies, often monthly or annual No term, but the build is paid for up front A minimum term (ours: 12 months)
Who maintains it The vendor Your developer or in-house team The provider, with hosting, support and updates in the monthly price

When is off-the-shelf order processing software the right answer?

Off-the-shelf tools are good at the common case, and plenty of businesses are the common case. Subscription software is likely to suit you if:

  • most of your orders arrive in a handful of consistent formats
  • your ERP is well supported by the product, and you use it in a fairly standard way
  • one or two people process orders and you don’t expect that to change
  • you want something running this month with very little set-up
  • you want the lowest possible upfront cost
  • you aren’t sure automation will stick, and want to try it with a short contract first

A short trial of a subscription product is also a cheap way to learn what you actually need. Even if you move to something else later, you’ll know far better what to ask for after a few months of using a tool that almost fits.

When does a custom build win?

Having a system written for your business alone makes sense in a narrower set of cases:

  • Your process is unusual. Nothing packaged or platform-based comes close, and the gaps would always need workarounds.
  • You have someone to look after it. An in-house developer, or a long-term arrangement with an agency, to fix it, update it and change it as you grow.
  • You can fund it up front. A build carries the largest day-one cost and usually takes longest to go live.
  • You want to hold the code yourself. For some businesses that matters more than the cost.

A build also needs time from your team to agree what’s being built and to test it. When the original developer moves on, someone else has to pick it up.

When does a managed platform win?

A managed platform makes sense when the gaps between your process and an off-the-shelf product start costing you time or money, but a build looks like too much. Typical signs:

  • Your checks are specific to you. Customer-specific price lists, minimum order quantities, account holds, delivery charges that depend on the carrier. If the software can’t check them, someone still checks by hand.
  • Orders touch several systems. An ERP, a web shop, a warehouse and a carrier, where an off-the-shelf product only connects to one or two of them.
  • Your customers are messy. Scanned PDFs, spreadsheets, orders split across an email and its attachments, customers using their own product codes. The more variety, the more a generic tool needs workarounds.
  • You don’t want to run software. Hosting, backups, support and updates are handled for you, and on our Standard and Growth plans a set number of tweaks to your integration come with the monthly price.
  • You want a far lower starting cost than a build. You pay to connect a proven platform, which costs far less than writing one.

The catch is that the monthly price runs for as long as you use it. There’s a minimum term, and at low volumes even our £295 Essentials plan can be hard to justify on time saved alone. You also need to give some time to supplying sample orders and testing your integration on real ones.

How should you compare the cost?

Add up the total over three years. A build puts most of the cost up front, while off-the-shelf software and a managed platform spread it out, so the totals often land closer together than the first quotes suggest.

The cheapest option on paper is only the cheapest if it handles your orders. If someone still checks customer prices or keys web orders by hand because the software can’t, that time belongs in the sum too. For our own pricing at different volumes, see what order automation costs.

Questions to ask before you commit

Some costs only show up later, so before signing up for any order processing automation software, ask:

  1. Can we export our data, including order history and audit logs, in a standard format?
  2. How much notice do we get of price changes, and is there a cap?
  3. What happens to our data when the contract ends, and how long do we have to retrieve it?
  4. How long is the minimum term?

If you’re having something built, add two more:

  1. Who looks after it when the original developer moves on?
  2. What does maintenance cover, and what’s charged as extra work?

Fit with your ERP

This is where the options differ most in practice. An off-the-shelf product connects to your ERP in the way its developers chose, which works well if your set-up matches their assumptions. Where it doesn’t, you see it in the details: the PO number lands in the wrong field, delivery charges are added as the wrong line type, or a customer’s special price list is ignored.

A custom build is written against your ERP as you actually use it. On a managed platform, the ERP connection is part of your integration, so it’s configured for the way you work. Either way, a sales order should land exactly as your team would have entered it, with the customer’s PO number as the reference and invoicing carrying on unchanged. We’ve written more about this in sales order automation into your ERP and on our ERP integration page.

Making the decision

If you’re unsure, start with the inexpensive test. Collect a week of real orders, list every check your team makes before an order goes in, and see how much of that list an off-the-shelf product handles out of the box. If it handles nearly all of it, buy the off-the-shelf product. If the gaps are where most of the time goes, price a managed platform alongside a build and compare them over three years.

We’re happy to look at that list with you on a free discovery call, and we’ll tell you if an off-the-shelf tool is the better fit.