All insights

How to reduce picking errors in a wholesale warehouse

A customer rings to say their delivery arrived with twelve of the 22mm fitting and none of the 15mm. The picker was experienced, the shelf was the right one, and the pick list was correct. The two products sit side by side in near-identical boxes, and the pick list described them by a code nobody reads.

That is how most picking errors happen. To reduce picking errors, remove the moments where a picker has to interpret, remember or guess, and add a check at packing that catches what still slips through. Better staff training helps, but the bigger gains usually come from changing the information and the layout people work with.

What counts as a picking error?

It helps to be specific, because each kind has a different cause:

  • Wrong item: a similar product, the wrong size or the wrong colour.
  • Wrong quantity: one pack of ten instead of ten singles, or a miscount on a busy shelf.
  • Missed line: a line skipped on a long pick list, often on a second page.
  • Wrong order: goods from two orders packed into the same box, or labels swapped.
  • Out-of-date order: a line the customer changed or cancelled after the pick list was printed.

If you only record “mis-pick” in a complaints log, you can’t tell which of these you have, and the fixes are quite different.

Why do pick and pack mistakes happen in small warehouses?

In a large distribution centre, every location has a barcode and every pick is scanned. In a warehouse with a handful of staff, picking usually relies on knowledge and a printed list. That works well most of the time, and the errors cluster around a few weak points:

  • Lookalike products stored together, often because they share a product group.
  • Pick lists in the customer’s order, so the picker zigzags across the building and loses their place.
  • Ambiguous units, where the list says “10” and the shelf holds both singles and packs.
  • Paper that goes stale. The office amends an order after it has been printed, and the warehouse never hears.
  • No check between picking and sealing the box, so nobody compares what is packed with what was ordered.
  • Interruptions. A phone call or a forklift halfway through a long order is when lines get missed.

Ten practical ways to reduce picking errors

Not every fix needs software. The first few cost very little; the later ones are where devices and an order platform help.

  1. Separate lookalike products. Move near-identical items apart, or put a different product between them. It feels less tidy, but it removes the most common wrong-item pick.
  2. Make shelf labels match the pick list. If the list shows a description and a code, the label should show the same two things in the same order, large enough to read at arm’s length.
  3. State the unit on every line. “10 x box of 50” is unambiguous. “10” is not. Fix it at the order stage, where the unit is decided, so the warehouse never has to interpret it.
  4. Sort the pick list by where things are. Sorting by product group, then alphabetically, means the picker walks the building in one sensible route instead of in the order the customer typed the lines. Fewer trips back means fewer skipped lines.
  5. Tick every line as it’s picked. On paper or on a device, a line that hasn’t been ticked is a line that hasn’t been picked. On a device, packing can stay locked until every line is ticked.
  6. One order, one picker. Mark an order as in progress with the picker’s name when it’s opened, so two people can’t pick it at once and nobody packs half of someone else’s order.
  7. Refresh the order before picking. If the office can change an order after it’s approved, the warehouse needs the latest version when picking starts. Opening the order on a device and pulling it fresh from the ERP at that moment closes the gap that printed lists leave open.
  8. Take a photo at packing. Requiring a photo of each packed order before it can be completed makes the packer look at the box against the order one final time. It also gives you evidence when a customer reports a short delivery.
  9. Record weights at packing. Entering the weight of each parcel is useful for carrier booking, and a parcel that is far lighter or heavier than you’d expect for that order needs checking again.
  10. Log every error with its cause. Use the categories above. After a month you’ll know whether your problem is lookalike stock, units, stale orders or missed lines, and which of the fixes above matters most.

How do you know whether picking accuracy is improving?

You don’t need a dashboard to start. For every complaint or return involving the wrong goods, record:

  • the order number and date
  • which kind of error it was (wrong item, quantity, missed line, wrong order, out-of-date order)
  • who picked and who packed it, if you know
  • whether a photo exists and what it shows

Compare the counts month to month against the number of orders dispatched. Your own trend is the figure to watch. If one kind of error stubbornly stays, it points you at the next fix to make.

Photos make this far more useful. When a customer says a line was missing, a dated photo of the packed box tells you whether the error was in the warehouse or after the parcel left. Sometimes it shows the goods were there all along.

Where handheld devices help, and where they don’t

Moving from printed pick lists to rugged handheld devices addresses several causes at once: the list is always current, lines are sorted and ticked, orders are claimed by one person, and photos and weights are captured without anyone walking back to the office. Our earlier post on taking the paper out of pick and pack covers device choice, kiosk mode and Wi-Fi, so we won’t repeat it here.

Devices won’t fix a confusing layout or unclear units on the order. Those are cheaper to fix, so fix them first whatever you decide about devices.

If you hold thousands of fast-moving SKUs across many aisles, with a large picking team, a full warehouse management system with barcode scanning at every location may be the right investment. For a warehouse with a few staff and a few hundred product lines, a simpler device-based process connected to your orders is usually enough, especially when it’s set up around your own layout and product groups.

Fixing errors before they reach the warehouse

Some picking errors start in the office. An order keyed with the wrong product code or quantity will be picked perfectly and still be wrong. Checking each line against your ERP for product code, unit and price when the order is first reviewed means the warehouse is working from an order someone has already validated. Our post on why the order approval step matters explains how that review fits in.

Our warehouse side is available on request alongside any of our plans and quoted separately, as it isn’t part of the plan prices. If you’d like to see how a device-based picking and packing process would work in your building, take a look at our warehouse solution or get in touch to talk it through.